May 30th, 2008

lj idol

Challenges - Part 2 - Week 29

A few words from tru2myart:

Good morning and welcome to Challenge Number 2!

First, let me thank all of you for the outpouring of support. When I asked Gary to submit the first challenge I never dreamed so many people would come back and join in. I am thrilled and I can only hope this is an upward trend.

Now, I didn't do a very clear job of explaining WHY I issued the first challenge in my last entry and I wanted to be sure to clear up any confusion. So here, by way of three cups of tea and a lot of late night thinking, is my attempt at a concise explanation:

I'm trying to raise community spirit.

No really, that's it. I want to see the community bond again.

I've been a participant here for the last three seasons. When Gary told me I wasn't able to take part in Season 3, or any season thereafter, I was disappointed but after what I gained from playing this "game" there was no way I was just going to walk away. Any chance I had to chime in with topic ideas, game twists, anything Gary would listen to, I was going to do it. He rarely listens to me but I've stayed anyway. :D

The spirit in the community dwindles at the end of every season, that's pretty much a fatal fact of almost any online contest. If you're not able to participate you tend to drift away until you can participate again.

However, I've noticed a real downard spiral in the community spirit here than I've seen in seasons past, especially in the last few weeks. It may just have been me personally but it had me concerned. All of you have worked so hard these several months, I couldn't stand the idea of seeing Idol take such a sad turn at the end of it all. Especially since the final four are still writing their wee hearts out to stay in it.

So I thought to myself, why did we all join in in the first place?

Well...speaking for myself, it's because I wanted the glory of it all, the winners hat, the million dollars....

Other than a very lovely icon there was no prize. What I won was my writing talent back. It's not the best and brightest talent but it's mine and relish it and it was this competition that gave it back to me.

And it occurred to me that noone would have stayed in this thing for all those months, struggled and fought that hard to get entries in on time, put their lives on hold and bit that bullet unless they really loved to write.

What better way to bring everyone back, get that community spirit brewing again than to get everybody writing one more time?

And in doing so I've noticed more people taking an interest in Idol as a whole. I've been reading the entries and I've seen commenters who never participated before contemplating joining next season. And if they're interested in the community they're going to stop in and read and what better way to support the final four as well than to get new readers interested and involved?

Spirit, spirit, spirit!!

So that's my thought process behind the whole thing and hopefully it makes sense as it's 7:30 in the morning and the three cups of tea are not killing the desire to go back to bed after only 3 hours of sleep.

That being said, CHALLENGE NUMERO DOS!!

Please pick four more topics from the topic groups and post them back here by Sunday, June 1st 3 PM fake time EDT. You can write all of the, one of them, none of them. You can just read, comment, whatever you'd like, it's up to you. This challenge is writer's choice, a way to support your finalists as well as challenging yourself to write again. Writing those last four entries for me was hell but really invigorating, how 'bout you guys?

You can find the topics in the topic threads where you can also find the entries that the final four are writing. I owe the final four an apology, I had meant to post a link back to their entries in my last challenge but I kept editing and editing to get it right and completely forgot the last most important paragraph.

I won't forget this time.

They are the most important reason we are all still here:


Their entries are here and
here .

Please read them and give them your love and support.

That's all for today. Write on Writer McWritersons!!

Just a note on the above, I think one thing that Penny (and other people ) tend to forget is that *it's nice outside*right now in most places. Not only do people drift off in the last few rounds (until the final when they all seem to come back for a look-see) but when it's around this time of year, it doesn't matter who you are or how much people love you, it's difficult to compete against the great outdoors.

I am proud of the people who have come out to play the Home Game this round! FOUR OF YOU are actually Final Four competitors in previous seasons! So you know how tough it can be!

That said - I have MY CHALLENGE TO YOU. I want you to follow those links above for the Final Four's entries as they continue to come in. Read, and let them know what you think. Not just a "you rock", but actually what it brings out in you. Quality responses are always better than lots of them after all.

Happy Birthday to the the Great and Powerful Internet helenangel, Imabirthdaygirl and masterofmusings!!!!
lj idol

About Tulip_in_Yellow

Awhile ago I asked the current contestants if they would mind if I posted a few fairly off the top of my head comments about each of them. They said that would be ok. I almost did it at 7, then 5, but I didn't want to space any of them out around a vote. . . so now seemed like as good of a time as any.

I reserve the right to edit once I start hearing people yell.*g* But it's the things that crossed my mind at the time when I sat down to think about each of them. They all are around the same length and cover the same categories.

We will be having four of these - one a day for the next four days, in alphabetical order according to user name. This is the fourth and final entry.

Consider each entry to be your chance for a mini fan club gathering to talk about what YOU LIKE about each contestant and their writing.


Odds of Winning: 1/4

Full Disclosure: She has been on my friends list the longest of the four.

First Impressions: I noticed her fairly early, and much like kittenboo had a good feeling about her lasting awhile. But considering the size of her friends list at the time I wasn't quite sure how it was going to happen.

Writing: The quote that I liked was that she has magical, accessible work that brings the reader along for the ride, which knowing her, could be just about anywhere. Which is completely true. She has a way of bringing a sense of place and energy to her writing.

She reminds me of tru2myart, both in the feel of her writing and tendiency to attack solid walls head first when she felt she had a point to make.

Social: She was a frequent Green Room commenter throughout the season and I think that had a lot to do with people checking out her work and getting to know her back when the field was crowded and kept herself a highly visible figure in the community.

"Game": She has a pimping for votes alliance with one of her closest friends since day 1.

Other than that, to match her own blunt style, I'd have to say that her "game plan" has consisted of telling people exactly what she thought of everything and everyone without very much of a filter. She's the only person I've ever seen who's *had a friends cut DURING a season as the race got tighter*. I think that sums her complete no nonsense approach nicely.

She was named as a target back in when several "power players" were trying to throw each other under the bus. Which is why, when confronted, her name was brought up and it was taken to mean she was one of my favorites by folks wanting to distort things for their own benefit.

Current Impressions: Serious threat to take it all. Solid writer with a stubborn streak a mile long. If there's a way to win through sheer determination and drive, she's the one most likely to find it.

She has a solid base of support within the community as a well as a network of friends and supporters who love her work, and that can make all the difference.